John Catsimatidis on Donald Trump, Immigration, and New York Republicans

Businessman and political figure John Catsimatidis, known for his affiliations with Donald Trump and his past employment of Curtis Sliwa, engaged in a conversation with The New York Editorial Board on December 11, 2025. Catsimatidis, who owns radio station 77 WABC and previously ran for New York City mayor in 2013, was joined by Richard Weinberg, a former judge and current commentator on 77 WABC.

During the discussion, Catsimatidis touched on several topics, including the mayoral race, the Republican Party's prospects in New York, and immigration.

Ben Smith initiated the conversation, which included Nicole Gelinas, Josh Greenman, Alyssa Katz, Ben Smith, and Liena Zagare.

Catsimatidis inquired about the atmosphere at The New York Times, referencing his past friendship with Arthur Sulzberger and suggesting a decline in common sense compared to earlier times.

Regarding the mayoral race, Catsimatidis admitted that he hadn't paid much attention to The New York Times' role. He noted that everyone had been focused on his involvement with Curtis Sliwa, emphasizing that he had no control over Sliwa's campaign. Catsimatidis also mentioned President Trump's initial preference for Cuomo in the race.

When asked about a Republican primary, Catsimatidis stated that he would have considered running if he had foreseen the eventual outcome. He speculated about the potential influence of foreign money in Mamdani's campaign, though he later apologized for the assertion when pressed for evidence.

Catsimatidis also addressed the challenges facing the Republican Party in New York, citing difficulties in fundraising. He noted the changing demographics of the city, with a growing Asian and Muslim population, and advocated for Voter ID to ensure fair elections.

Weinberg added that the Democratic Party is under siege from DSA types and the Working Families Party.

Discussing the profile of a Republican candidate who could win against Mamdani, Catsimatidis emphasized the importance of focusing on quality of life issues in New York. He also defended Trump's stance on immigration, recalling a conversation where he urged the former president to prioritize deporting criminals before considering broader measures.

On the topic of immigration enforcement, Catsimatidis expressed concern that ICE may have exceeded its authority and called for cooperation with federal authorities on serious criminals only. Weinberg argued against Sanctuary City laws, citing the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution.

Addressing concerns about the incoming Mamdani administration, Catsimatidis suggested that cooperation with Trump on affordable housing could benefit New York City. He also raised questions about rent payments in NYCHA, highlighting the need for solutions to address non-payment issues.

Weinberg voiced concerns about Mamdani's policies, including his stance on homeless sweeps and cooperation with federal authorities, warning of potential public health crises and a decline in quality of life.

Catsimatidis reiterated his support for immigration but cautioned against an "invasion" of people seeking to change the American way of life. He emphasized the importance of immigrants assimilating and working hard.

Regarding the grocery business, Catsimatidis revealed that his supermarket businesses are struggling due to high rents, shoplifting, and competition. He suggested that government subsidies or cooperation with national chains could help lower grocery costs.

When asked about energy policy, Catsimatidis expressed skepticism about government subsidies for solar energy but supported nuclear power as a future alternative. He also criticized windmills, citing their environmental impact and reliance on foreign governments.

Looking ahead, Catsimatidis predicted a strong US economy in 2026 but expressed concerns about the current state of New York City. He cited high taxes and a declining quality of life as reasons for potential future relocation to Florida.

In closing, Catsimatidis reiterated his belief in common sense and his desire for a secure and prosperous future for New York City and the United States.